Different Approaches To Teaching Reading

Holkham Hall - the rooms inside - The Librarie...
Holkham Hall - the rooms inside - The Libraries - book shelves (Photo credit: ell brown)
by Hannah McCarthy

Identifying the most effective way of teaching reading to young children has been the subject of fierce debate for many decades.

The two most popular methods have been the 'phonics' approach and the 'whole language' approach. These two methodologies approach teaching reading in very different ways, which has led their proponents to attack each other's approach as misguided or even detrimental to a child's learning.

But what are the characteristics of each approach and how do they aim to build the reading skills of young learners? Furthermore, is it really possible to argue that one is better than the other? Here's an attempt to answer those questions.

Phonics-based teaching

The phonics approach tries to create an association in the child's mind between the 'graphemes' (written symbols) and 'phonemes' (sounds) of language. Through the use of repetitious exercises to drill this link between text and sound, teachers aim to build a familiarity and comfort with the basic building blocks of written texts.

Once the child has achieved this proficiency, teachers then encourage them to blend the individual written elements together to produce whole words; this is known as the 'synthetic approach'. As such, synthetic phonics is described as a bottom-up approach which builds towards comprehension through a journey from the smallest elements of written texts.

Advocates of synthetic phonics claim that an emphasis on the child's ability to 'decode' written texts is essential for creating a foundation on which an understanding of meaning can be constructed.

Its detractors, on the other hand, decry the rigour and repetition of phonics, arguing that children are often bored and disengaged by the slavish focus on rules and individual sound-text associations. The discipline required for this approach gives it a traditionalist, back-to-basics quality that has a recurring appeal for generations of educators.

Whole-language teaching

The whole language approach focuses on comprehension from the outset, with children being given continuous texts to read in order to build an understanding of vocabulary and meaning. These texts will be short, often with words being repeated to help develop familiarity with certain key terms and concepts.

A teacher will initially read with the children, but will gradually say less to encourage more independence on the part of the young learners. Placing trust in children's ability to build associations between words and draw conclusions from the text, whole-language teaching has been identified as a top-down approach which places less emphasis on the rules and minutiae of language.

Those in favour of whole-language teaching praise its student-led approach, arguing that it is both more engaging and more meaningful for young learners. Critics claim that such an approach places a strain on teachers and that it lacks the structure and clear objectives of the phonics method.

A balanced approach?

With the differences between advocates of the two approaches at times appearing intractable, some have argued that a mix of the two methods is most appropriate, allowing teachers to combine the best of both worlds. This may be true, although it could be argued that a divided focus on bottom-up and top-down approaches can be confusing for young children.

Whatever the solution, it's generally agreed that different children have different preferences when it comes to learning to read, so teachers would be well-advised to monitor to which methods children respond best and tailor their teaching accordingly.

Hannah McCarthy works for Education City, a leading supplier of e-Learning software for schools in the UK. Education City offers comprehensive curriculum-based resources for teachers, including a range of literacy activities and a new Learn English module for teaching English as an additional language.

Article Source: http://EzineArticles.com/?expert=Hannah_McCarthy
http://EzineArticles.com/?Different-Approaches-To-Teaching-Reading&id=7235143

Enhanced by Zemanta
You have just read the article entitled Different Approaches To Teaching Reading. Please read the article from Excellence in Education About , more. And you can also bookmark this page with the URL : https://uncollected-luke.blogspot.com/2012/08/different-approaches-to-teaching-reading.html
Previous
Next Post »

8 comments

Write comments
Unknown
AUTHOR
November 25, 2013 at 2:16 PM delete

I recently came across your blog and have been reading along. I thought I would leave my first comment. I don’t know what to http://www.essay-writings-service.com/

say except that I have enjoyed reading. Nice blog. I will keep visiting this blog very often.I’ll use this information for my essays.

Reply
avatar
hamsphire
AUTHOR
August 15, 2016 at 9:07 AM delete

There are different tools that are used for reading method for students. The phonics are different in different countries. Beside this you can order custom term paper for better services that are perfect for the students in exams specially. You can add more topics and can get the papers.

Reply
avatar
aliyaa
AUTHOR
July 1, 2017 at 3:00 AM delete

The discipline required for this approach gives it a traditionalist, back-to-basics quality that has a recurring appeal for generations of educators.
http://www.personalstatementwriters.com/low-income-personal-statement/

Reply
avatar
July 22, 2017 at 2:14 AM delete

شركة تنظيف
شركة تنظيف منازل بالخبر
تهتم شركة قمم التميز باعمال وخدمات التنظيف فى اى مكان فى تنظيف الشقق – البيوت – المنازل – المصانع واى مكان يحتاج الى اعمال التنظيف من اجل ان تساعد فى الوصول الى افضل ما تجدة من نتائج مميزة
تنظيف يحتاج للاشياء معقدة من الادوات ، مثل الغرف المنزل لها ادوات التنظيف الخاصة، الصالون المدهب يحتاج لمنظف الخاص ، وسطح فى المنزل يتطلب مواد متخلفة ، فكثير من المنظفات المطلوبة حتى تكون عملية التنظيف سهلة ومن المنظفات : مبيض التواليت ، منظف الحمام، المطهرات ، المنظف للنوافذ والارضيات والغسيل ، سائل الغسيل و اعمال المنزل الصغيرة يمكن انجازاها بفوطة جافة ومنظف جيد ، المنظف المصنوع بقل الامكنيات ، معلقتين من الخل الابيض مع لتر من الماء الساخن وضعهم فى بخاخة . بيكربونات الصوديم لتنظيف البلاط يمكن مزج ثلاثه اجزاء من الماء الساخن مع جزء من الصودا لتنطيف الفرن والثلاجة ، وبيكربونات الصوديم بقليل من سائل الجلى يتكون معجون سميك صالح لتنظيف الحمام ، يمكن استخدام بيكربونات الصوديم وضعه فى صحن صغير ولطرد الروائح الكريهة من الثلاجة ، كربونات الصوديم فعالة فى ازالة البقع الدهنية لانها قلوية ويجب لبس قفازات لاستخدامها . شركة تنظيف موكيت بالخبر
الخل الابيض وعصير الليمون يمكن تنظيف السطوح الزجاجية والخشبية المصقولة ، ويمكن استخدام الخل الابيض والليمون للتخلص من الروائح الكريهة والتعطير .
عند التنظيف يجب لبس القفازات لحماية الايدى من المواد المنظفه ، ويمكن لبس الفقازات عند غسيل الصحون وتكون مخصص لعمل فى المطبخ .
والمنزل النظيفة من غير فوضوى أجمل بكثير وافضل ،وإذا توفر جميع الادوات النظافة داخل بيت تكون عمليه النظافة سهلة ،شركة تنظيف كنب بالخبر
للتنظيف المنزل من اعلى الى اسفل ، اى تنظيف الغبار من اعلى الى اسفل ويمكن استخدام الاجهزة الكهربائية فى عملية التنظيف .
تنظيف النوافذ باستخدام قطعة قطنية فى مسح الزجاج وللتجفيف بورقة من الجرائد ، وتنظيف الاسطح الزجاجية للمنضدة باستعمال عصير ليمون ودعكها ثم تجفيفها بفوطة ورقية. ويمكن استعمال معجون الاسنان فى ازالة الخدوش الصغيرة من الزجاج . شركة تنظيف واجهات وزجاج بالخبر
لتنظيف الاثاث استعمال منظف على قليل من نشادر ، عدم وضع الاثاث فى أشعه الشمس فالشمس تجفف الأثاث ، للتخلص من الحلقات التى تكون على المنضدة بقليل من المنظف مع النشادر ثم مسحها بفوطة جافة ثم تلميعها بالملمع .
لتنظيف الحمام باستخدام الادوات النظافة الخاصة للحمام فى الحمام ، تنظيف السيراميك والمرايا باستخدام مطهر الجراثيم وتنظيف كل شئ فى الحمام مثل مقبض الباب ومفتاح الكهرباء ، والتخلص من القاذورات فى الاركان الضيقة فى الحمام ، تنظيف الخلاطات المياه ومسحها بقطعة قماش مغموسة فى خل او زيت الطعام ، لتنظيف الحمام باستخدام المناديل المعقمة ومسح منطقة الدش والمرحاض .
شركة تنظيف واجهات حجر بالخبر

Reply
avatar
Protech13
AUTHOR
December 25, 2017 at 5:17 AM delete

مرحبا بكم في موقع العاب بنات و العاب طبخ !
هنا ستجدين تشكيلة كبيرة من العاب بنات بالمجان للعب و الاستمتاع.
قومي بزيارة مختلف اقسام الموقع و ستجدين العاب تلبيس ,العاب بنات ستايل,العاب طبخ ايضا العديد من العاب البنات 2018
و لربما انت من المحبين للزينة و الملابس الجميلة اذن نوع العاب تلبيس.
يناسبك اما اذا كنت مولوعة بالعاب الزينة و الموضة فستجدين العديد من العاب بنات ستايل هنا. بعض البنات تحب لعب العاب ترتيب الغرفة و الاعتناء بها من اجل الباربي
لذا من الافضل لعب العاب باربي. منهم من يحب الطبخ و فنونه فما عليكي الا اختيار افضل العاب طبخ التي نقدمها .
بالطبع اذا احببتي لعب العاب بنات 2018
مجانا فستجدين ما يناسبك ما عليك الا حسن الاختيار و ستعجبين العاب الجديدة. التي نقدماه لكم ,كونو اوفياء!

Reply
avatar
Shawn
AUTHOR
March 19, 2018 at 5:20 AM delete

Critics claim that such an technique locations a strain on teachers and that it lacks the structure and clean goals of the phonics approach. those texts might be short, Essay Help Online often with words being repeated to assist increase familiarity with certain key phrases and concepts.

Reply
avatar
pslv seoa10
AUTHOR
March 22, 2019 at 9:32 PM delete

Reading Buddy Software is advanced, speech recognition reading software that listens, responds, and teaches as your child reads. It’s like having a tutor in your computer

Reply
avatar
Sumit Mishra
AUTHOR
March 10, 2022 at 4:03 AM delete

Thanks for giving so much of Information. There are many Students looking for english tutor

Reply
avatar